Friday, April 6, 2012

Lucas Leiva's Position - Defensive Midfielder? Volante?


Lucas at Gremio
For people with nothing better to do than discuss the miniscule details of football, the natural position of Lucas Leiva has been a much covered, and much disputed topic.  His transition from a more attacking player whilst at Gremio, to a holding role or defensive midfield position at Liverpool, has a lot to do with differences in style of play and the way positions are assigned in Brazil and England.  The need to pin players down to a particular description or positional term has created much confusion about Lucas’s part in a football team, and may have given his managers at Liverpool a headache or two.  Ultimately it is the manager who decides which position a player is stationed in, and how much freedom they have to stray from this starting role.  Here we will try to define the various roles Lucas has played, and what might be his best position.

Lucas started his career at Gremio, a club based in Porto Alegre in southern Brazil, where he began to draw ambitious comparisons with Brazilian great Falcão.  These comparisons were made because of the style of play, the strengths Lucas showed on and off the ball, and the positions he took up on the field.  In Brazil, the position of players like Lucas and Falcão before him, is given the name Volante.

Volante

Volante is a general term for a player taking up a defensive midfield role. The word may have roots in the name of Argentine player Carlos Volante, who was one of the first to play the position during the 1930s. It literally translates into English as Flywheel – a rotating device used as an energy store – or steering wheel.  These translations themselves begin to paint a picture of what the player in this position will provide for a team.  They are very much the fulcrum of attacks and the engine room of defence, and will use their technical ability to engineer attacks whilst also being able to garner the energy to break up opposition moves.  It’s often easy to define the position semantically, but then the hard part is matching the player to the positional description.

Brazilian teams often play with two players in this position, with one taking up a stricter defensive role who will recycle the ball quickly when in attack, and another player who has more license to get forward and less defensive constraints.  This is where the term volante is expanded to include the terms first and second volante, and where we find the term which best describes Lucas during his time at Gremio.  As a second volante he has all the drive and defensive traits of a defensive midfielder, but was also able to use this same determination to compliment his technical ability going forward, as shown in this slightly dodgy video of him scoring for Gremio.  Here the team is on the attack and Lucas sees the opportunity to make a late run into the box to get on the end of a cross, and shows how a well timed run can turn a volante into an attacking midfielder.



There are many other examples of Lucas playing for Gremio where he would be described as a playmaker due to his probing passes, a box to box midfielder with his energy and running, an attacking midfielder getting on the end of attacking moves, and a defensive midfielder left holding the fort.  At Gremio it’s safe to say that he was seen as a great all round midfielder and footballer, and these all round performances saw him win the coveted Bola de Ouro in 2006; an award previously won by Brazilian luminaries such as Zico, Mauro Silva, and Falcão.

Transition in Liverpool

The transition from playing in Brazil to being a regular in the English Premier League is a difficult one, and it was no different for Lucas.  The difference for Lucas was that he always had the mental attributes to succeed in the league, and these attributes tended to dictate the positions he was employed in by Rafa Benitez, who signed him for Liverpool in 2007.  Liverpool had a strong midfield at the time Lucas joined, including the likes of Xabi Alonso, Javier Mascherano, and Steven Gerrard, with other fringe players such as Mohamed Sissoko and Damien Plessis also vying for a place in the team.  This meant Lucas had to adapt, and maybe take up a more specialised role to find a way into the side.

Lucas was initially seen as the ideal partner for Mascherano if Liverpool wished to play a more defensive formation with two more defensive minded midfielders.  This was seen as a great system for Lucas to play in, as he had alongside him a player who might be familiar in style from his time in Brazil, with direct comparisons to make between the first and second volante combination.  And there won’t have been many better volantes to play alongside and learn from than Javier Mascherano.

Similarly, playing and training alongside Steven Gerrard and Xabi Alonso would have helped to encourage improvement in the attacking and creative aspects of Lucas’s game.  You could say that Lucas possessed some of the qualities of all three of these world class players, but this could also have been the reason he struggled to settle into a rhythm during some of his early seasons at Liverpool.  In a league where specialisation and clear definition in certain positions seems to be demanded by fans and pundits, and in a team where those ahead of him in the squad were some of the best exponents of these specialised positions, many began to lose patience and faith in the midfielder as he tried to find a role in the side.  Defensive midfielder, playmaker, or attacking midfielder?  Which one would he chose?

Volante II

After the departures of Xabi Alonso and Javier Mascherano, Lucas found himself in the Liverpool first team more often than not.  As the seasons progressed the mistakes became fewer and Lucas’s confidence on the ball increased.  In the 2010/11 season Lucas played an important role in the Liverpool side, often partnering Christian Poulsen, Raul Meireles, or Steven Gerrard – with Lucas the mainstay of the side as the others around him struggled for form or fitness.

The position he found himself in was similar to that vacated by Javier Mascharano, so he had effectively stepped back from the second volante he was at Gremio, to a more disciplined generic volante.  He recycled the ball well between defence and attack, doing the simple things well and allowing others to express themselves further up the pitch.  Liverpool’s manager Kenny Dalglish commented that:

I don’t think Lucas is going to be the one who beats five or six players and puts it into the back of the net. But he may be the one who stops the guy going past the first fella then sets us on our way

His job in defence was more prominent in that he became an expert in breaking up opposition play and often stifled some of the more revered attacking midfielders in the opposing teams.  This meant he seemed to pick up a yellow card in almost every game, but also meant that he was one of the most successful tacklers in European football.  This is best summed up by Opta in their tweet:

172 - Lucas Leiva made more tackles than any other player in the top five leagues in Europe this season. Cult.

Another successful tackle.
This willingness to defend and play for the team saw Lucas voted as Liverpool’s fans player of the season for the 2010/11 season, and also showed how the mentality of a volante he brought with him from Brazil, has helped him to convince his doubters that he has an important role to play in the team.

More recently Lucas has seen himself the lynchpin of the Liverpool midfield, allowing Charlie Adam or Steven Gerrard the freedom to get forward and spray passes around to the attackers.  It’s no surprise that Adam’s performances have dropped since Lucas has been out of the side with an injury, and Liverpool’s form in the second half of the 2011/12 season has shown how much they miss him.

The Future

Second volante / attacking midfielder / playmaker / defensive midfielder / anchor man / box to box midfielder.  Clearer now?

Lucas celebrates with Luis Suarez.
The two players could be key players in Liverpool's future plans.
Further reading:

No comments:

Post a Comment